Tilting at Windfarms

"The greatest scar on the landscape is those annoying windfarms. Areas of outstanding natural beauty are being ruined by these monstrosities."

Monstrosities? Just a minute.

A wind farm

A coal power station

Now, which one of these is the greater 'scar on the landscape'? It's not a trick question, I promise.

Once again the readers of Country Life magazine have entered the news by complaining rabidly about things most people don't mind. They have voted wind farms their #1 most hated eyesore.

These complainers might live in the countryside, but it's obvious that they don't give a damn about the environment. All they care about is their own environment, defined as what they can see from their patio. We invest money into developing cleaner sources of energy, and when the research pays off, these people quibble about the aesthetics? Never mind the fact that eight out of ten people in the UK are in favour of wind energy, or that most people think windfarms look unobjectionable, interesting, or even elegant.

I swear, if all that was needed to permanently eradicate war, disease and famine was the construction of a single structure, some people would still fight it if they would be able to see it from their kitchen window.

It's the same with everything... the people who feel the strongest always make the most noise, usually disproportionately so. Wind farms get a lot of negative coverage in the media because most of the people who are talking about wind farms are the tiny minority who strongly oppose them. I think we need to make an effort to redress the balance. So here goes...

I want a wind farm outside my house. I promise I won't complain -- in fact I'd support it completely. Wind based electrical generation is a good thing -- it's cheap, clean, and practical. I like wind farms!

What I write on this blog isn't going to make a bit of difference, of course. But shouting into the ether is surely no less Quixotic than tilting at windfarms.

There's a ton of information about windfarms and wind energy at the British Wind Energy Association website.

19 Comments

Your page seems to be very one sided. I am a realist and think Wind Power could be a very good thing. However you should take the info from BWEA with the full knowledge that they are NOT a government body but have been set up by the wind industry to talk on their behalf and to lobby for them. IE they are a totally one sided commercial concern paid for and run by over 290 private companies that build windfarms, acquire land, supply legal advice, supply equipment, finance as an investment, and those that own the wind farms or hope to make a profit from their construction.
Please also note that a wind farm is only about 23% efficient at best. IE they only produce usable power 23% of the time. Also that huge investment in the National Grid needs to be made first so that all the generated power can be used. Denmark has probably the best grid system in Europe and the longest running development history of integration of wind farms. BUT they are now considering closing those very wind farms because of the serious problems they cause with the supply system. This is not being anti wind farms..I am just saying yes lets have off shore wind farms but lets make sure their generated power can be used first and not rush in and build loads of wind farms that then have to be turned off because they cause overload power cuts.. It takes several years for a wind farm to recoup it's environmental (CO2-loss of land etc)cost if all the power is used. If it cant be accepted or leads to power cuts then the idea will be badly damaged and lose support. Do it right first time. Remember that their generated power has to be heavily subsidised as well. It would NEVER stand up on an economic basis if their power was sold at market value. Lots of people are making lots of money from wind energy, pity it cant all be put back in….
Leading civil engineers, ecologists and environmentalists have warned about this from the start. Wind energy can only every be part of a much larger effort to save the environment. Just putting them up will do very little on it’s own. You need to use all their power for the maximum amount of time. Arguments like, “Well at least we are doing something” are at best naive. If you build them and it turns out they are not working and their power cant be used we may never have another chance.
the evidence is documented and real

I agree with Andy T, wind power stations may help, but their very small, unpredictable contribution which does not replace any other generation is not worth destroying all our upland landscapes for. Other technology is coming on fast - for instance placing turbines in tidal streams is being tested and will produce reliable, plannable power which really will save fossil fuel generation. Hill-based wind factories are only a short-term fashion, produced through government subsidy and industry seeing a quick buck

Alfred ist mit das geilste, was das deutsche Fernsehen je geboten hat. Ich finde die Serie klasse. ;)

man yakhjiam. In chiz haaeee hastesh keh man daram test mi konam. Hala nemidoonam javab mideh ya na

awesome writing for this an excellent storie a lot of people that write articles online don’t get completely credit and i would like to say thank you for your good work. I adore the page layout as-well you really getting this page around. I have just tweeted this post. I was kinda looking for this for a while and i will tell my comrades about this blog the will beenticed by thanks

@Casimira Behrman I do not like your thinking. You may take that type of post somewhere else.

colocamos nosso background em respeito ao grande ator LESLIE NIELSEN!

The Danish tradition of Living ! :)

So wonderful post.I am bursting to leave a comment.I am also a fan of "fashion",you are an example to all of us.Thank you for teaching me so much.Good job.

While still capable of being quite effective (he was great as Big Daddy in Kick-Ass and as the titular rogue in Werner Herzog's reinterpretation of Bad Lieutenant), it seems that, recently, all he's been doing is adding his dwindling Oscar cred to a series of subpar projects.

But believe it or not, the shoes do much for them, a girl, when a trailer was reported by the madness of a great brand of shoes. She is aware that a pair of shoes to do as much or more for your entire look of your costume and make-up.

I have to accept your statement about it issue and not just for the reason that that is my business. I have dealt with lots of people who spent a long time trying to find a way through proper understanding of this topic. They were always always frustrated. Always play strengths and understanding, and if at all possible, get the advice of a qualified person to handle the parts you can't ever handle yourself. In the long run, you will have great end result. Thanks for the tips I came across on your site.

hi-ya, I like all your posts, keep them coming.

I've been browsing on-line greater than 3 hours as of late, yet I by no means found any fascinating article like yours. It¡¦s lovely price enough for me. Personally, if all website owners and bloggers made good content material as you did, the web can be much more helpful than ever before.

Youre probably right, but I am encouraged that a lot of people are beginning to understand that governments debt is so large now that its going to cost everyone a lot of money in new taxes and reduced benefits. Thats a start. Its still not too late to save this country, but if we dont stop the insane government spending soon, it will be too late. As soon as most people get on the governments payroll, well find ourselves in the same shape as Greece, California, and New York; ie, more non-productive workers than productive workers, and the non-productive workers are voting themselves more and more benefits and pay on the backs of the dwindling number of productive workers. If government was a business, it would go out of business very quickly doing things like this.

Im not going to say what every person else has already said, but I do wish to comment on your information of the topic. Youre genuinely well-informed. I cant believe how much of this I just wasnt aware of. Thank you for bringing much more data to this topic for me. Im really grateful and genuinely impressed.

Simply desire to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is just cool and i could assume youre an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

Genau hatte ich selbst im Netz gesucht. Danke für diesen Post. Werde deine Posts weiter verfolgen.

I really like your site and I just heard a really cool band called ANTENNA, they are awesome. You should check them out. Keep up the good work with your site.

Leave a comment

Close